Rate The Player Above

DeletedUser11183

Guest
This is a simple game; and a world forum would never be complete without it.

Rate each of these category's for the player who has posted above. If possible give a reason for your choices.

Points- x/10
Area- x/10
ODA- x/10
ODD- x/10
Tribe- x/10
Forum- x/10

Total- /60

REMEMBER TO LEAVE YOUR IN GAME NAME AT THE END OF YOUR POST.

Ill Start; The Icemen



P.S. Rep Appreciated as always ;)
 

DeletedUser9136

Guest
The Icemen

Points- 9/10 - 160 points, rank 22, Aslong as it's backed up with troops, nice work!
Area- 8/10 - Short term, A farming heaven!! barbs and inactives galore! but very few potential noble targets for the future
ODA- N/A - BP
ODD- N/A - BP
Tribe- 8.5/10 - Rank 15, but 4th highest average, possibly one to watch
Forum- 9/10 - 110 posts, seen you around before, always good posts

Total- 34.5/40

TopGun13
 

DeletedUser

Guest
TopGun13

Points- 7/10 - about average points atm, can't fault it
Area- 4/10 - close barbs are good, however too much competition for farming
ODA- x/10
ODD- x/10
Tribe- 9/10 - 1st atm, however have already hit 39 members which questions the recruitment structure of the tribe
Forum- 4/10 - i can't say much but only 10 posts, however i havn't been on the forum for ages

Total- 24/60

zeelbeno
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Points- 9/10 - High up in the ranks so good start up so far
Area- 6/10 - It's not the best but still good
ODA- x/10
ODD- x/10
Tribe- 2/10 - The tribe will fall eventually
Forum- 6/10 Haven't posted much until yesterday.

Total-25 /40

Nexanim
 

DeletedUser11183

Guest
Nexamin
Points- 9/10 Not bad, top 20
Area- 10/10 i love it so much, :(
ODA- x/10
ODD- x/10
Tribe- x/10 not gunna comment as its my tribe :)
Forum- 8/10 been posting alot since uk14 started.

Total 27/30

The Icemen
 

DeletedUser9522

Guest
Points - 10/10 Rank 2, not much room for improvement there.
Area - 10/10 No competition and several barbs
ODA - N/A
ODD - N/A One of the few in the world to be attacked by a barb
Tribe - N/A My tribe, not commenting
Forum - 8.5/10 Seeing a lot of posts in the W14 section.

Total - 28.5/30

M40A3 Disciple
 

DeletedUser7025

Guest
M40A3 Disciple

Points - 9/10 growing nicely and at the top end of the rankings.
Area - 8/10 little competition and several barbs /bonus vills. May have issues finding a target when nobles come out
ODA - na
ODD - na
Tribe - 9/10 some real quality in there and clearly selective with recruitment.
Forum - 9/10 busy bee :D

35/40 should go well


IGN Fullmetalprophet
 

DeletedUser8924

Guest
Fullmetalprophet

points- 9/10 rank 3 nice :)
area- 8/10 good area,i hard area maybe? not hard,just needs to be cleared asap if he wants to take his growth to the next lvl
ODA- NA
ODD- NA
Tribe- 6/10 his own tribe,only 11 members atmo,good average per player,altho i think after a while they will get gangbanged by the local tribes if they dont look to diplomacy-early days? yes, definatly.time will tell
fourm- 6/10 ok altho i havn't realy seen him that much...

29/40 has the posiblity to go a long way,it all could depend a desision....

Beani
 

DeletedUser11475

Guest
Beani

points- 7/10 not that high
area- 8/10 looks quite nice
ODA- N/A
ODD- N/A
Tribe- 5/10 40 members is too much imo
fourm- 6/10 idk

PreservationSociety
 

DeletedUser11183

Guest
PreservationSociety

Points - 9/10 Great for start date.
Area - 9/10 tons of farms and a few targets for when you get nobles
ODA - 10/10 fine, done a bit of clearing or hit spikes, no more then i'd expect
ODD - n/a
Tribe - n/a, its my tribe ;)
Forum - 7/10 I see you trollin'

34/50 should go well

The Icemen
 

DeletedUser

Guest
The Icemen

Points - 9/10 Strong growth, rank 3.
Area - 8/10 lots of farms, some nice targets to build villes, some stiff competition
ODA - 5/10 ok, a few troops lying around in farms or a spike or two
ODD - n/a
Tribe - 7/10, looks fairly strong
Forum- 7/10, always here to liven up the place

36/50 good stuff so far

packman1980
 

DeletedUser

Guest
packman1980

Points - 5/10 average looking start up
Area - 4/10 looks a fairly active area - slim pickings i think - hope you are concentrating on troops - think you gonna need em. on the bright side your makum neighbour should be an good place to start (W12 experience ;) )
ODA - 9/10 rank 5 - you obviously do have some troops! :)
ODD - n/a
Tribe - 2/10, doesnt fill me with confidence tbh
Forum- n/a ive been away for while n bit out of touch

20/40

average start, average area, less than average tribe - dont look too good atm tbh...

however if your early decisions are better than on W12 (FAF... really? no wonder you didnt stay), can see an aggressive offensive style getting you into a bigger tribe in time, tho looking at your history youve either not found one you fit into yet, are very indecisive or dont have much loyalty to your teammates... good luck...
 

Nauzhror

Well-Known Member
Reaction score
106
Zipper2

Points: 5/10 Average-ish for someone even remotely active.
Area: 8/10 Amazing looking area, which you don't appear to have taken advantage of. Possible you've farmed more than I think though and that your troopcount is actually high, but at least point-growth is very disappointing for such a great area.
ODA: 3/10 Too high. Contrary to what others may claim high OD is not good for an accounts growth.
ODD: 0/10 not been attacked thus far
Tribe: 2/10 Not only do you have a brother tribe but it has a member near me who is incredibly isolated and shouldn't have been recruited because he has less than a snowball's chance in hell of surviving in his current area. Especially when his village looks like this.

18/40

IGN: Social Experiment
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Social Experiment

Points: 9/10 Standard. Do I even need to comment? You will be rank 2 by the end of today most likely (overtaking mbig) currently rank 3.
Area: 8/10 I know you will argue or disagree with this, but I would be happy with this area and actually do think its fairly good. You have been outfarming nearly everybody on this world and will continue to do so.
ODA: 5/10 I know you never clear people early on meaning those are either from clearing inactives quest troops and hitting spikes. Ouch.
ODD: 5/10 It's 1.
Tribe: N/A It's my premade so I can't really comment without being biased.

27/40

The Icemen
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Points- 9/10
Area- 9/10...Pretty beasting
ODA- N/A
ODD- N/A
Tribe- 7/10...See if they last.
Forum- 5/10

Total- 30/40


Squirting-Cream
 

DeletedUser8412

Guest
Points- 9/10 Rank 4 atm going strong. Heard it was all down to meechan though
Area- 6/10 Nothing special
ODA- N/A
ODD- N/A
Tribe- N/A Wont comment. My tribe
Forum- 10/10 Judging the acc owners forum accounts not that one.

Total- 25/30

Black Descent
 

DeletedUser11475

Guest
Black Descent

Points- 9/10 Rank 6 Pretty decent.
Area- 7/10 looks alright
ODA- 9/10 low not lost much
ODD- N/A
Tribe- 9/10 only other tribe I've really noticed
Forum- 8/10 random rating:p

PreservationSociety
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Cadan. said:
Now we know your ign :D
Click to expand...

No he is Squirting-Cream, he is saying rate preservationsociety because he posted above him and Matt was replying to someone.

Rate PreservationSociety because nick rated last!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top