Noble Planner

[DeletedUser]

I have a few questions about this new facility.

1 It seems that only the claimant can add comments.
2 The planner can be shared (according to the screen) but is it share all or nothing?

There are generally 2 main resons for planning claims:-

1 Approval by a group of senior tribe members eg a a noble claims officer.
2 Letting other tribes know what is being claimed to avoid cross nobling.

The forums allowed information sharing and comments from anyone.
Different claim forums could be set up and shared with different tribes.

1 It seems there is no way that "approval" can be given using the noble planner.
2 There is no way to share ONLY certain claims eg within a particular K with another tribe.

I can't help feeling that the planner - whilst brilliantly integrated into the game, fails to tackle the critical issues that the forums were able to.

My tribe are currently discussing the planner and I'm interested in comments from people already using it.

Les

 

[DeletedUser]

I have a few questions about this new facility.

1 It seems that only the claimant can add comments.
2 The planner can be shared (according to the screen) but is it share all or nothing?

There are generally 2 main resons for planning claims:-

1 Approval by a group of senior tribe members eg a a noble claims officer.
2 Letting other tribes know what is being claimed to avoid cross nobling.

The forums allowed information sharing and comments from anyone.
Different claim forums could be set up and shared with different tribes.

1 It seems there is no way that "approval" can be given using the noble planner.
2 There is no way to share ONLY certain claims eg within a particular K with another tribe.

I can't help feeling that the planner - whilst brilliantly integrated into the game, fails to tackle the critical issues that the forums were able to.

My tribe are currently discussing the planner and I'm interested in comments from people already using it.

Les

First of all i don't get the use of a "Noble approver" as you say.

But as to other tribes knowing what you claim if it is something you want another tribe to see you can actually.
If you don't favor the noble planner it is not something you have to use it is just a more efficient noble claimer than making topics in forums.
Again i still dont see the need for an approval? :icon_neutral:
You can share the noble planner completely with another tribe.

 

[DeletedUser6855]

im loving the new noble planner

just a query due to questions raised in one of the tribes im in who use it for all our claims

we have had people who are not with premium account's
state that they can not see the padlock on the tribe claimed villages

being premium iv not seen this first hand and was more trying to find out if this is actually correct
or are they just making excuses
for steal claims
or is this really the case ???????????????

 

[DeletedUser]

im loving the new noble planner

just a query due to questions raised in one of the tribes im in who use it for all our claims

we have had people who are not with premium account's
state that they can not see the padlock on the tribe claimed villages

being premium iv not seen this first hand and was more trying to find out if this is actually correct
or are they just making excuses
for steal claims
or is this really the case ???????????????

the padlock thing i am not to sure about but if they can't see it without premium then it must be a premium feature.
But even so they can still check the actual noble planner itself

 

[DeletedUser6855]

seems a total waste of the piece of kit

If its only a premium feature
then it would
be a total waste for any tribe to use it and surely defeats its purpose

 

[DeletedUser5475]

does it not pop up a red warning on the "ok" screen that says, "warning a tribe member has a claim on this village." or something to that effect...

 

[DeletedUser]

seems a total waste of the piece of kit

If its only a premium feature
then it would
be a total waste for any tribe to use it and surely defeats its purpose

Get premium then, pritty much sorts it out:icon_wink:

 

[DeletedUser6855]

Get premium then, pritty much sorts it out:icon_wink:

lol
well i am
im just as happy using one of the external noble claimers
as i am this one
and i do see the reasoning but a true
shame the script writers greed didn't see past there wallets
as far as the small percentage that little touches like this can be off putting!! to new players, and them long term who enjoy playin without one