Rate the Player

DeletedUser

Guest
Well this forum is dead as can be. As much as I dislike threads like these, we need to give some life to these forums.

Rules are simple. Rate the player above based on the following categories.

Tribe: ?/10
Rank: ?/10
ODA: ?/10
Profile: ?/10
Personality: ?/10

Sub Total: ?/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: ?/10
ODD: ?/10
Internal/Barb Caps: ?/10

Total: ?/80

I'm on DrHufflepuff with my lovely co-player and the account owner, Stephen

 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser

Guest
DrHufflepuff
Tribe: 8/10
Rank: 8/10
ODA: 9/10
Profile: 9/10
Personality: 5/10 (I prefer Stephen :p)

Sub Total: 39/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 10/10
ODD: 10/10
Internal/Barb Caps: 8/10

Total: 67/80

ItWillBeOverbyChristmas

Tribe: ?/10
Rank: ?/10
ODA: ?/10
Profile: ?/10
Personality: ?/10

Sub Total: ?/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: ?/10
ODD: ?/10
Internal/Barb Caps: ?/-10

Total: ?/80
 

DeletedUser13584

Guest

ItWillBeOverbyChristmas

Tribe: 10/10
Rank: 7/10
ODA: 6/10
Profile: 8/10
Personality: 8/10

Sub Total: 39/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 8/10
ODD: 6/10
Internal/Barb Caps: 8/-10

Total: 61/80



jamie.s

Tribe: ?/10
Rank: ?/10
ODA: ?/10
Profile: ?/10
Personality: ?/10

Sub Total: ?/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: ?/10
ODD: ?/10
Internal/Barb Caps: ?/-10

Total: ?/80
 

DeletedUser

Guest
jamie.s

Tribe: 4/10 - Some good players in this tribe but doesn't change that it is a mass recruit tribe that bullies the smaller ones.
Rank: 8/10 - Top 20 is nothing to scoff at.
ODA: 9/10 - 4th in the world. Well done.
Profile: 7/10 - Sometimes simplicity is ok.
Personality: 10/10 - Both players on this account from what i have seen are friendly and know what banter is. Not over the top, just goofing off in the world chat.

Sub Total: 38/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 9/10 - 37 gains, 6 losses. For this war that is a respectable number.
ODD: 10/10 - You're up there.
Internal/Barb Caps: 4/10 - 47 of your 115 Villages were free. Either Internals or Barbs.

Total: 61/80 - Overall, not a bad score.

Rate Drhufflepuff.

Tribe: ?/10
Rank: ?/10
ODA: ?/10
Profile: ?/10
Personality: ?/10

Sub Total: ?/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: ?/10
ODD: ?/10
Internal/Barb Caps: ?/10

Total: ?/80
 

DeletedUser13734

Guest
Rate Drhufflepuff.

Tribe: 4/10 - I don't know Flair very well, but you seem to be the only one holding off lol.
Rank: 9/10 - not in top 10, but considering starting late and getting to where you are now is impressive to say the very least.
ODA: 7/10 - 3m isn't bad as a rim player.
Profile: 7/10
Personality: 9/10 - quite extravagant, tells a good and interesting story and that's where my rating comes from - your interest in the game. Quite serious on the world chat though from what I've seen.

Sub Total: 36/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 10/10, You've got great stats in the war, I'm shocked as to how many vills you've actually managed to get.
ODD: 5/10, you haven't defended much from what I know.

Internal/Barb Caps: ?/?

Total: 51/70



*GranTorino

Tribe: ?/10
Rank: ?/10
ODA: ?/10
Profile: ?/10
Personality: ?/10

Sub Total: ?/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: ?/10
ODD: ?/10
Internal/Barb Caps: ?/-10

Total: ?/80
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser7967

Guest
GT

Tribe: 9/10 - Love the trib! great members! but as allways, small problems lol.
Rank: 10/10 - Rank 5, well done!
ODA: 10/10 - Rank 1, Nothing more has to be said..
Profile: 8/10 - It's a profile.. lol
Personality: 10/10 - :*

Sub Total: 47/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 10/10 - You are doing great!..
ODD: 9/10 - you are doing great!..
Internal/Barb Caps: 9/10 - Impressive.

Total: 75/80 - All most perfect!.

Rate Mbig.

Tribe: ?/10
Rank: ?/10
ODA: ?/10
Profile: ?/10
Personality: ?/10

Sub Total: ?/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: ?/10
ODD: ?/10
Internal/Barb Caps: ?/10

Total: ?/80
 

DeletedUser13584

Guest
mbig

Tribe: 10/10
Rank: 10/10
ODA: 10/10
Profile: 9/10
Personality: 9/10

Sub Total: 48/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 9/10
ODD: 7/10
Internal/Barb Caps: 7/10

Total: 71/80
 

DeletedUser13734

Guest
Jamie.s

Tribe: 10/10
Rank: 10/10
ODA: 9.5/10 ( not quite up to me yet m8 ;)
Profile: 8/10
Personality: 9.5/10 (youre a bit of a moaner, but other than that you're sound ;) )

Sub Total: 47/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 10/10
ODD: 10/10
Internal/Barb Caps: 8/10 (

Total: 75/80
 

DeletedUser13665

Guest
*GranTorino

Tribe: 6/10 - you know my opinions ;)
Rank: 9/10
ODA: 10/10 - rank 1 ... nuff said
Profile: 8/10
Personality: 9/10 - you know i love you ;)

Sub Total: 42/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 9/10
ODD: 8/10 - not quite mine ;)
Internal/Barb Caps: 9/-10

Total: 68/80

rate: spofh then blockywizard (17th sept owards)
(b gentle ;) )
 

DeletedUser13734

Guest
Spofh

Tribe: 3/10 - That's not your fault ;)
Rank: 10/10 - Top 10, Now you just have to hold it :)
ODA : 9/10 - That's a nice number, but from your size it could use a little bumping!
Profile: 5/10 - Bit boring ;)
Personality: 9/10 - I love you too ;)

Sub Total: 30/40

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 0/10 - Do you have so much against SCO that you don't want to take their villages ? ;)
ODD: 2/10 - Am I going to have to come over and give you a spanking to get that number up ??
Internal/Barb Caps: 7.5/10 - Had quite a few, but not compared to others.

Total: 44.5/80
 

DeletedUser13755

Guest
*GranTorino

Tribe: 6/10 - I think you're a better player than the tribe your in if i'm honest.
Rank: 9/10 - Top 5 is impressive when you're in a high action zone. Your points per village are at a good number too considering those barbs you took on the west.
ODA: 10/10 - No.1 with half of it coming from the Vodka vs SCO war. Impressive.
Profile: 7/10 - Noting too flashy, love the report.
Personality: 9/10 - Been active and fun to speak to in the world chat, only thing I can base it on when the externals are pretty quiet.

Sub Total: 41/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 8/10 - average of 4. Very nice considering your frontline. Also average of 1mill ODA per village so you either fought hard for your caps or used your troops to benefit others a lot.
ODD: 8/10 - Top ten, seem a jack of all trades. Good show for the villages you have lost.
Internal/Barb Caps: 6/10 96/181 - Not all fought for but sometimes what you need to do is not the flashy move.

Total: 63/80

Good score overall, keep going how you're going and you'll be a force to be reckoned with.

Stephen AKA the better half of the Drhufflepuff account.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser13859

Guest
Drhufflepuff

Tribe 10/10 - Who doesn't love what Flair is about
Rank 9/10 - Started after me and your well ahead now.
ODA 9/10 - As above,
Profile 10/10 - Keep the village names, almost reads like a story. Plus your PA makes it 10/10
Personality 9/10

Sub Total - 47/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps 10/10 - Most war caps from anyone still playing.
ODD 8/10 - We'll need to wait for someone to attack you though.
Internal/Barb Caps 9/10

Total 74/80

Great score.

Will - Warlord9
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser

Guest
Warlord 9

Tribe: 7/10 - I like Flair, everyone I have spoken to in the tribe have been friendly despite being enemies
Rank: 7/10 - Top 30 is nothing to be laughed at
ODA: 6/10 - Would like to see it match his rank though (not that I can talk, though I am working on it)
Profile: ?/10 - Nothing on their but tribal wars staff comments, assume it was something offensive on it prior to it so can not comment
Personality: ?/10 - Never spoken to Warlord so can not comment


Sub Total: 20/30


Bonus Categories
War Caps: 6/10 - A few takes from S.C.O, but with the location of his base expected a lot more active. Small tussle with Whatever it takes it seems, should be doing better against a player that size
ODD: 8/10 - Good ODD, one assault seems to of added 5.1 million ODD at the expense of 6 villages. Should maybe of lost few considering the distance of the assault origin
Internal/Barb Caps: 6/10 - 51 barb/internal takes out of 91 villages


Total: 40/60

Rate: Dags00 till 19th September, then Will O Baron
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser11220

Guest
Will O Baron

Tribe: 10/10 No doubt
Rank: 10/10 3rd in world and thats just now
ODA: 9.5/10
Profile: 7/10
Personality: 9.5/10 Works with me in ops and im hard to put up with so say it all

Sub Total: 46/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 10/10
ODD: 7/10
Internal/Barb Caps: 7/10 Just cause of merge

Total: 70/80
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser

Guest
Beer Slayer

Tribe: 10/10 Some awesome tribe mates
Rank: 9/10 Top 5, in my opinion suits his ability in this world
ODA: 9/10 Top 15 ODA
Profile: 10/10 Who doesn't like Beer?
Personality: 9/10 Admittedly, had some fallings out at times. But Beer is direct and straight to the point which I appreciate and we are working well together now


Sub Total: 47/50


Bonus Categories
War Caps: 10/10 Great war caps, I think Beer only lost 1 village too?
ODD: 7/10 Value is lower than expected for a player of Beer's size, but is it his fault if no one attacks him?
Internal/Barb Caps: 9/10 Very few internals, most of the barbs taken were large villages



Total: 73/80

Rate: Dags00 till 19th September, then Will O Baron
 

DeletedUser13755

Guest
Can't find Dags00 stats so I will only do Will O Baron.

Tribe: 5/10 - Though making headway on the NE front things are a little lackluster down here. Think you're a little held down by your tribe.
Rank: 8/10 - Top 3 warrants a 9/10 but with APPV (Average points per village) being fairly low it means there were quite a few easy conquers to be had.
ODA: 8/10 - Top 10 is always good but considering your points and size I feel you could be a little higher up there.
Profile: 7/10 - I've seen the idea quite a few times whilst playing. Ironically I had one in my tribe who went with the same idea before being banned for using illegal scripts. Bad bot was bad. Simple is good though, no need to clog up your profile.
Personality: 9/10 - Down to earth when needed but also very confident of yourself. Your personality backs up your performance for sure.

Sub Total: 37/50

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 9.5/10 - Top of the pile and going strong, the 4 against took the .5 because beer slayer is showing you up a little ;)
ODD: 8/10 - Not the highest but 2.5mill for only 4 village losses is a strong showing.
Internal/Barb Caps: 8/10 - 63/234.. I am going to be very kind and not put the Dags00 caps as internals since it was your old account :) Good showing there.


Total: 62.5/80

A strong position and I see no real headway into stopping you. I see great potential for the future as you are also on the rim.

Drhufflepuff - Stephen.
 

DeletedUser11220

Guest
do me your detailed plus like to know where need to improve
 

DeletedUser13755

Guest
Beer Slayer

Tribe: 5/10 - Same as the above..
Rank: 8.5/10 - Top 5 is the place to be, shows you commanded your area. With a high APPV it also means the villages you have are action ready.
ODA: 7/10 - The difference in your ODA and war caps/villages tells me you like to go for bleeding targets. Though a completely valid strategy and working so far your ODA has suffered at little.
Profile: 9/10 - Short, sweet and made me laugh. Goes with the name, though the Picture is a little generic.
Personality: N\A/10 -I'm sorry, since we haven't really spoken, nor have I heard much about you I can't make a judgement there. I'm sure you're lovely :)

Sub Total: 29.5/40 - Mainly low due to the tribe here.

Bonus Categories
War Caps: 10/10 - Based on the current war you're 60-0, I don't know what position you were at in previous wars so i cannot comment. To take so many for no loss is a very strong boast indeed though it does pose the question of if there was much standing in the way? (Nothing you can do about that so no points deducted)
ODD: 6/10 - Honestly quite low considering your position on the front, obviously haven't been pissing off the right people! again not really in your control but as I am rating your ODD I cannot give you a high rating for what seems to not have been fully tested.
Internal/Barb Caps: 7/10 - 77/181 seems to be your score here, very low on barbs however your account seems to have started on internals. Since you have used that to then turn it onto the enemy I will keep it at a 7.

Total: 52.5/70

Overall you're doing well, I feel you haven't been tested properly but that is the fault of your enemy and nothing on you. My advice would be to not get complacent, just because you haven't been targetted yet doesn't mean it's not coming.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top