Meado on 11.04. at 01:38
Hey there,
One of your tribe seems to be attacking a member of mine - may I ask why this is happening, we are supposed to be allies?
The attacks are from midgey - and they are not a farming trip gone wrong, as there is 15 of them! The player has refused to respond to my players attempts to contact him.
Please get back to me as soon as possible on this,
Meado
Baron of -ODA-
debbie.b on 11.04. at 07:21
Please let me know who is being attacked as you didn't mention it in your mail. I have checked with midgey and he tells me he is only attacking one player at present who isn't in your tribe.
deb
debbie.b on 11.04. at 11:01
I think you have been misinformed here as the villa was only taken last night the attacks were already on their way. So it is not a case of attacking an Allie but some cross nobles!
Deb
Meado on 11.04. at 12:38
15 nukes/nobles to take this tiny village? I find that difficult understand. Here is the first report;
I am inquiring into when the attacks started, and if my player confirms that they were coming in when he took the village and weren't sent after, I'll consider this closed.
Meado
debbie.b on 11.04. at 12:49
Well we all work in different ways! I am sure you are more than able to check the walking distances yourself and this will confirm that the attacks were sent before it was taken!
As for considering it closed I am not sure I do. why did your player not dodge and save an allies troops?
Deb
Meado on 11.04. at 16:07
Indeed we do.
He says he cant tell if they were sent before or after, so I'll take your word for it.
And would you have dodged if you were going to lose a village to another player?
debbie.b on 11.04. at 16:14
How can he not tell?..please check the walks for yourself...they were sent before!
In this situation it is usual to dodge so that troops are not killed! especially Allies troops!
deb
Meado on 11.04. at 16:15
You don't need to prove that point, I believe you on it.
And I would disagree. If a LRAG player had nobled a village in one of your Ks, came on a few hours later and found 15 incoming from us, they would have reacted exactly the same. No player willing gives up villages if they can hold them.
debbie.b on 11.04. at 16:24
Wouldn't expect them to give up the villa...but I would expect them to protect an allies troops and only kill what was needed to keep the villa.
deb
Meado on 11.04. at 16:31
And we did that, to the best of our abilities.
debbie.b on 11.04. at 16:37
ok well I will get the reports sent to me...and if thats the case I would expect to see some troops returning. I have seen one already and the troops were killed...we need to talk about compensation when I have seen the full reports
deb
Meado on 11.04. at 16:39
The reports will probably show your player losing most, if not all, of his troops. As far as I am aware, the support in the village from our players has been taking hits but has not been wiped as of yet.
debbie.b on 11.04. at 16:43
So he is not dodging...you said
Author wrote:Meado today at 16:31
And we did that, to the best of our abilities.
Is that any way to treat allies?
deb
Meado on 11.04. at 16:44
How can he dodge when the support belongs to other players?
debbie.b on 11.04. at 16:47
OK so now you are telling me that ODA are supporting and kiling an allies troops?
deb
Meado on 11.04. at 16:49
I've been telling you this from the start - ODA are defending their villages from agression. We would do so against anyone, allied or not! Just because a player attacking us is an ally doesn't mean we are going to let them attack us.
debbie.b on 11.04. at 16:52
It wasn't an ODA villa when the attacks were sent!
Meado on 11.04. at 16:53
And we didn't know that then, did we?
debbie.b on 11.04. at 17:01
What did you not know? your guy took a villa is it not beyond the bounds of reason that some one else may also be attacking the same villa?????
I really don't undestand your attitude to this. It is a simple case of cross nobles. Now we are being accused
Meado on 11.04. at 17:11
I do not understand your confusion - any attack coming to a village is treated as an act of agression.
And 15 attacks isn't considered cross nobling. 4-6 attacks would be seen as a cross nobling. 15 is complete overkill for one village.
Yes we have established now that it was cross nobling, but it is a bit late to stop your players troops dying. So why do you keep bringing this issue back up?
debbie.b on 11.04. at 17:21
I assure you I am not confused.
The amount of attacks is insignificant as they were not sent to an ODA villa. A fact which you seem to completely miss. Therefore it was not an act of agression against ODA
Meado on 11.04. at 17:59
They attacks were coming to an ODA village, and as such is it hard to see why they were percieved as agressive acts? Yes, between yourself and myself we have now established it was cross nobling and it is not an act of agression, but at the time it was seen as one.
debbie.b on 11.04. at 18:16
I think a lot of the problem is that your guy wasnt active when he took the villa and therefore wasnt sure that they were already incoming. As I would assume that your response would be completely different if that was the case.
Meado on 11.04. at 18:19
Indeed it would have - but one must do what one can, based on the information one has at the time.
debbie.b on 11.04. at 18:33
Ok...so as your guy was not active. Wouldn't it have been better to admit that! I have ended up with one of mine loosing troops. Hardly LRAGs fault or indeed his. I mailed you this morning to let you know this but you have still continued to kill his troops. I will expect compensation for him.
Meado on 11.04. at 18:39
I am not blaming LRAG or him, I was defending my reasons for assuming it was his fault based on the information I had at the time.
We aren't compensating him for his losses.
debbie.b on 11.04. at 20:04
Yes I understand that ... and the information you now know was wrong. You said your self if you had the full information you would have acted differently. The very least you can do is compensate him for his losses. Which could have been prevented if your player was active and dodged the main attacks
