I think any player that is intelligent enough to follow a 'guide' and make it work will probably soon end up in a tribe surrounded by experienced players .
Again you must consider what is success. The people in this thread advocating success through guides have only really done well early game.
In my opinion you can easily build villages , noble, farm, be a top ranked player but unless you have come under heavy attack and proved your worth , thats not really a whole skilled player ,just someone very good at that part of the game.
I hear there are a lot of skilled players in w3 . Some I have never seen play before . I think the proof of skill comes to the light when people fight each other. This also I believe is one of the best ways to learn that part of the game .
Guides are ok for starting up , a mentor to teach you more, the 'Baptism of Fire' to test your own actual skill , such as responses , intuition, timing, multitasking , sniping , backtiming , working under pressure etc.
A lot of the better players I know were thrown in the deep end and came under heavy attack in their first world and fought well from the onset , others like me , have followed guides , got into a cushy tribe and been 'moddly coddled' and never came under attack till pretty late into playing , and not enough to claim to be skilled.
I hope W3 is a great opportunity for the skilled players to show their skills but also at the same time those they fight will be able to learn a lot from fighting them.
<3